Wednesday, July 05, 2006

Wednesday Boot

In today's edition Max complains about pampered troops yet manages to miss the point:

In the past few months, I have traveled across U.S. Central Command's area of operations — a vast domain stretching from the deserts of Arabia to the mountains of the Hindu Kush. Everywhere, I have found massive bases fortified with endless rows of concrete barriers and stocked with every convenience known to 21st century Americans.

Some front-line units continue to operate out of spartan outposts where a hot meal is a luxury and flush toilets unknown. But growing numbers of troops live on giant installations complete with Wal-Mart-style post exchanges, movie theaters, swimming pools, gyms, fast-food eateries (Subway, Burger King, Cinnabon) and vast chow halls offering fresh-baked pies and multiple flavors of ice cream. Troops increasingly live in dorm-style quarters (called "chews," for "containerized housing units") complete with TVs, mini-refrigerators, air conditioning/heating units and other luxuries unimaginable to previous generations of GIs.

[...]

Most of our resources aren't going to fight terrorists but to maintain a smattering of mini-Americas in the Middle East. As one Special Forces officer pungently put it to me: "The only function that thousands of people are performing out here is to turn food into [excrement]."

How to explain this seemingly counterproductive behavior? My theory is that any organization prefers to focus on what it does well. In the case of the Pentagon, that's logistics. Our ability to move supplies is unparalleled in military history. Fighting guerrillas, on the other hand, has never been a mission that has found much favor with the armed forces. So logistics trumps strategy. Which may help explain why we're not having greater success in Iraq and Afghanistan.


Max is seemingly upset that the Pentagon is unserious about the war(s). Well, as the the saying goes, the fish rots from the head. George and Dick and Rummy aren't serious so why should the Pentagon planners be serious? George and Dick and Rummy wanted a photo-op, a way to gather power, a demonstration of "strength", but by all means George and Dick and Rummy didn't want Americans to think there was actually, y'know, a war.

So as Afghanistan collapses back into a failed state (soon to be joined by Iraq) Max is worried about troops' access to Starbucks. The "dying" part is an abastraction to him. And if Max stopped and considered that this unseriousness is due to the fundamental unseriousness on the part of George and Dick and Rummy his entire neocon worldview would disintegrate. And that's the one thing that Max would never be able to survive.


.