Monday, July 17, 2006

John Dean

John Dean's new book, Conservatives Without Conscience, is the latest to examine the modern Republican Party and where it is taking us and the world.

Dean, as most will know, went to prison for his part in Watergate. After removing himself from politics for nearly two decades he returned to the public eye in the late 1990's as a critic of the Republican persecution of Bill Clinton - especially during the Year of Monica. After the (shall we say?) disputed presidential election of 2000 he's turned into a tough and smart critic of the Bush Administration (his previous book was titled Worse Than Watergate: The Secret Presidency of George W. Bush) and the modern GOP.

This isn't to say that Dean has become a liberal or even a moderate - he planned originally to write the book with the late Sen. Barry Goldwater and has dedicated it to his memory - but that the Republican Party we see today has moved so far away from traditional conservative thought (that of Goldwater and even Nixon and Reagan) that it can't truly be called "conservative" anymore. Dean writes in the Preface:

Frankly, when I started writing this book I has a difficult time accounting for what had become of conservatism or, for that matter, the Republican Party. I went down a number of dead-end streets looking for answers, before finally discovering a true explanation. [...] Authoritarianism is not well understood and seldom discussed in the context of American government and politics, yet now it constitutes the prevailing thinking and behavior among conservatives. [...]


Drawing on University of Manitoba social psychologist Bob Altmeyer's studies of authoritarian personality - and, to a lesser extent, the controversial experiments conducted at Yale by Stanley Milgram - Dean lays out the case that the modern GOP has become a true danger to American democracy due to a confluence of fundamentalist Christianity (Dobson, Robertson), big money (The "K Street Project", Abramoff, Delay) and the particularly twisted views of Dick Cheney and his inner-circle. It's Cheney, enabled by the attacks of 11 September, 2001, that emerges as the pre-eminant "conservative without conscience" using the tragedy to consolidate power in the executive branch, a long-held dream of his. Aided at every step by an agreeable Congress (the authoritarian personality isn't limited to the will-to-power types but also to followers who find gratification - their own sense of power - in submitting to whom they see as "leaders"), Cheney has accumulated maybe the most power of any American official in modern times and possibly in the history of the Republic, all with nary a peep from a timid Democratic Party or the supposedly free press.

The key to this transformation is, of course, fear. The unprecedented secrecy of the first nine months of the Bush/Cheney Administration intensified after the attacks on New York and Washington as the Executive Branch made it clear: Give us the power we demand or you will die; deny us the power we demand and you are a traitor. (Terror alerts ceased on the day of the last presidential election and have only just started up again as we head into the thick of another election. This is not a coincidence.)

As Dean writes:

Bush and Cheney saw 9/11 as an excuse indulge their natural authoritarian and conservative instincts. In doing so, they have brought out the worst in conservatism: They have justified and rationalized their increasing use of authoritarian tactics in the name of fighting terrorism. Without terrorism, George W. Bush would likely have been a one-term president; with terrorism as a raison d’etre, Bush and Cheney’s authoritarianism has not been questioned seriously enough.


Answering the question, “are we on the road to fascism?”:

Clearly we are not on that road yet. But it would not take much more misguided authoritarian leadership, or thoughtless following of such leaders, to find our selves there. I am not sure which is more frightening: another major terror attack or the response of authoritarian conservatives to that attack. Both are alarming prospects.


As documented by Glenn Greenwald and Dave Neiwert, the violent, eliminationist rhetoric coming from the right has been increasing and even creeping into the vocabulary of “respected” members of the Republican Party. We may be farther down the road to fascism than Dean cares to admit.

After more than five years of the Bush/Cheney Administration we appear to be gaining an understanding of the situation we’re in. Along with Michelle Goldberg’s Kingdom Coming, Ron Suskind’s The One Percent Doctrine, and Kevin Phillips’ American Theocracy, Dean’s book provides deeper look at the motives of the modern GOP. Let’s hope the message the authors bring will be heeded.

The usual suspects: Amazon, B&N, Powell’s.


.