Wednesday, June 28, 2006

Wednesday Boot

Wow. Max seems a little depressed and - dare I say it? - thoughtful:

I have never been a dogmatist on the issue of troop levels. I was not one of those who criticized the original invasion force in 2003 for being too small. There were enough troops to take Baghdad, and there were legitimate reasons to fear that sending too many Americans would cause a backlash. Better to have focused on supporting Iraqi security forces — except there were none to support. The Iraqi army was dissolved by the U.S., and no serious effort was made for a whole year to field a replacement force, creating a security vacuum that has never been filled.

By now it should be obvious that the "light footprint" approach has not worked. It has increased, not decreased, resentment of the United States because Iraqis are aggrieved by the breakdown of law and order. Yet there appears to be no serious rethinking of this flawed strategy at either the Pentagon or the White House.

[...]

The fact that the administration continues to "stay the course" with a losing strategy suggests the need for a change of strategists. The president needs a new secretary of Defense — and possibly new generals — who would be more focused on finding a way to win rather than to withdraw.


Max argues that more troops rather than less are needed in Iraq. Maybe three years ago that would have worked but not anymore. Of course, the smart move would have been to not invade and occupy Iraq at all but at least he is trying to think this through. And the depressed tone seems to indicate that Max has looked into the future and is realizing that his neocon dreams are not to be.


.