Wednesday, June 14, 2006

The Lies and Distortions of Max Boot

This morning our pal Max Boot takes up the Bush vs. Truman "debate". After the usual maunderings about "outraged" liberals and a "sainted" Harry S Truman (if Truman is "sainted" it's largely because of David McCullough's hagiography) Boot gets down to some good ol' fashioned historical misrepresentation.

Boot sets up his thesis:

This is a refrain that has been heard since 2001, and it is worth correcting the historical record before this mythology becomes accepted as fact. The reality is that Bush is far more multilateral and Truman was much less so than commonly assumed.


Note that Boot cleverly transposes the words "mythology" and "fact".

For all of Bush's diplomatic stumbles, he has won the assistance of many allies in Iraq, the Horn of Africa and beyond.


Thanks, UK, Marshall Islands, and Uzbekistan! And what, exactly, is Bush doing in the Horn of Africa? Allowing Islamists to take over Somalia?

Much of the military effort in Afghanistan is being turned over to NATO, which, at Bush's urging, has gotten involved in a conflict outside Europe for the first time.


NATO, and pretty much the entire planet, supported the attack on Afghanistan. It was from there that the United States was attacked, after all. How's things going in Afghanistan these days, anyway? And good for NATO for fulfilling it's treaty obligations.

Did I say "treaty"?

Bush also has been active in pushing free trade, just as Truman did, through treaties (which many Democrats now oppose) such as the Central American Free Trade Agreement.


I wasn't aware that Truman equated "free trade" with "corporate giveaways". The things you learn from Max!

Bush, like Truman, has increased foreign aid.


See, again, Uzbekistan. Though that nation's dissident-boiling dictator seems to have wearied of us.

And in his approach to the North Korean and Iranian nuclear programs, Bush has been scrupulously multilateralist. Not successful but hardly unilateralist.


Well, it hasn't been successful with North Korea because the North Korean's argument is with the US and the US only. Multilateralism in this case is a delaying tactic. As for Iran, I'm feeling charitable so I'll give Bush that one. For now.

Skipping ahead a bit:

Acheson did make effective use of the U.N. in 1950, when he secured a resolution authorizing an armed response to North Korea's invasion of South Korea, but only because the Soviet delegate was boycotting the Security Council. In any case, Truman had already committed air and naval forces to combat before the vote. As he wrote to Acheson, a U.N. failure to act would not have altered his plans — "we would have had to go into Korea alone." Truman was equally clearheaded about the U.N.'s limitations in an earlier crisis — the British cutoff of aid to Greece and Turkey in 1947, which left those countries exposed to communist aggression. Truman told Congress: "The situation is an urgent one requiring immediate action, and the United Nations and its related organizations are not in a position to extend help of the kind that is required." So the U.S. offered $400 million on its own.


The Korean War seems to be the one issue the neocons keep coming back to in this Bush vs. Truman grudgematch. In 1945, after the defeat of the Japanese, Korea was partitioned between the Soviets (North) and the US (South). But something is always left out: By 1950 the South had its own government it also had a large contingent of American troops. The North's attack on the South was also an attack on United States troops. No president would simply run away under these circumstances. It's also worth noting that Boot and his neocon brethren never bring up the fact that Truman was damn near impeached for firing the megalomaniacal, insubordinate, and - in Korea at least - incompetent Gen. Douglas MacArthur.

The same pattern is evident throughout Truman's presidency. The decision to nuke Hiroshima and Nagasaki? A unilateral U.S. initiative.


The United States was the only capable fighting force left in Asia.

The Marshall Plan to aid European recovery? Ditto.


The United States had pretty much the only functioning economy in the world. And it should be noted that the Marshall Plan wasn't imposed on any nation. Participation was voluntary.

The 1948-49 airlift to break the Soviet blockade of Berlin? More unilateralism.


Unilateral in the sense that it had the support of every ally in Europe. So that would be multilateral in any non-tortured version of the English language.

Skipping ahead because he's so tedious, Boot concludes:

Multilateral camouflage like NATO can make the exercise of U.S. power more palatable, and it should be employed wherever practicable. But, whether in the late 1940s or today, progress on tough problems requires American action, alone if need be. That's something that both Bush and Truman understood — and that too many liberals still haven't come to terms with.


This conclusion is warranted only if one distorts history history to fit a predetermined idea. As Max has done.

Truman was conservative. Note that I write "conservative" rather than "right-wing". Today conservatives are a nearly extinct breed. Boot is no conservative; he understands that modern right-wing ideology demands lies and distortions to achieve its ends. (See: Strauss, Leo.) But the US, and the world, are ill-served by professional propagandists such as Max Boot.


.